IELTS Writing Task 1 Band 7.0

In this lesson:

✅ Real band 7.0 student answer
✅ What they did well
✅ What they can improve on
✅ Scoring for each criterion

In this video, we’re going to look at a real answer from a real student for this question that you can see on the screen right now. We’re going to talk about what the student did. Well and what they can improve on for next time. And at the end of the lesson we will talk about the band score. So let’s have a look at the question.

The pie charts show information about energy production. Okay. So that’s the topic. In a country, one country in two separate years. Now this is all that the students sent me. This is all that the question says. Now most of the time for writing task one, the question will ask you to talk about the main features. And it will also say make comparisons where relevant.

So I’m just going to assume that’s what the question is asking. So let’s have a look at the data now or the information. So the first thing I’m looking at is the years. So we’ve got 1995 and 2005. So when I look at that immediately I’m thinking of the tenths. I’m thinking that to describe this information, the student will need to use the past tense.

So we will see if they did that when we have a look at the answer. Now just having a look at the data, we can see that there are five main things nuclear, other coal, gas and Petro. And we can see that there have been some significant changes. So for example when it comes to Petro, it started at 29 and finished at 19.

So that’s quite a big drop. It looks like it’s a drop of about a third. So it looks like there’s some big changes here. However there are some small changes as well. So if we look at gas 29 to start with and 30 to finish up. So that is a very small change. So let’s have a look and see how the student talked about this.

All right. So let’s have a look at the answer from the student. We’ll go through it paragraph by paragraph. So let’s start with the introduction. The diagrams compare different types of energy production in France in 1995 and 2005. Well, that’s a nice sentence. There’s no grammar mistakes there. And it’s clearly telling the examiner what this report or what this answer is going to be about.

So it’s good in one way. However, it does look like there has been some repetition because in the question itself, the question talked about energy production. So where possible, try not to copy the question word for word. Now let’s move on to the next sentence. Now overall. Okay great. So this is going to be where the overview is.

It can be seen that coal represented the biggest proportion. Fantastic. While other kinds of energy production took up the least percentage in both years. So another great thing there. We’ve got an overall or an overview. So it’s clearly saying what the biggest number was. It said coal represented the biggest proportion. Fantastic. And then it said other kinds of energy production took up the least percentage in both years.

So it’s clearly talking about the highest number and the lowest number which is fantastic. Now another thing I see which could be improved, which could be improved on is energy production. So look what we’ve got. Energy production number one here. And then number two here. So there is a little bit of a repetition. Now just in regards to this phrase here where the writer or the student said took up the least percentage.

It just sounds a little bit awkward. It doesn’t sound very natural. So instead of saying that, I think it will be better to say something like accounted for. The smallest share. Smallest share. This sounds a little bit more natural, but overall I think the introduction is okay. It could be a little bit better, but it’s okay. But just by reading it, I’m thinking that this student is probably around a band seven, mainly because of this speed here.

About took up the least percentage because it just sounds a little bit awkward. And a higher level student like a band eight or a band nine probably wouldn’t make something make a sentence like this. All right, let’s move on to the next paragraph, which is body paragraph one. It starts by saying looking first at coal. Well, that appears to be a topic sentence.

And that’s great. That’s very important when you’re writing. However, I can see that they talk about gas as well and they talk about other as well. So it’s just not clear what the topic of this paragraph is. So that’s an issue straight away. It’s not a really big issue, but it is an issue nonetheless. Mainly related to coherence and cohesion.

So let’s keep going and we’ll see what the writer says. They say it had the highest percentage. Okay, great. That’s the main feature making up 29.8%. Nice grammar structure there of the energy production. There’s that, word or phrase again. Okay. Energy production. A bit of repetition. In 1995, whereas having had a slight increase reaching a percentage of 30.93% in 2005.

Well, again, there’s just something that doesn’t feel right with this little, part of the sentence here. So again, I’m getting that feeling of probably a band seven student. So what could we say instead of, whereas having had a slight increase. Well, instead of that, we could just keep it really, really simple and say something like. And increased slightly.

To. So hold on. Let me remove all of this. I’m sorry to keep 1995 and then finish off like this. So in 19 five 1995 and increased slightly to 30.93% in 2005. That’s much better. It has a much nicer flow, and a lot of the time a lot of students really like to try and write like this. So whereas having had a slight, they’re just trying to make it too complicated.

A lot of the time, simple writing is much, much better. So let’s continue now and have a look at gas. Gas representing a rather smaller. That sounds a bit funny. Rather a smaller proportion than coal. Made up 29.63 UK while having had a small increase. Yeah, so there’s that structure again while having had a small increase to that.

So instead of just going back to this first sentence, instead of saying representing a rather smaller, I think it will be better just to remove this word rather and say gas representing a smaller proportion than coal made up. And again, for this one here, while having had, we could just say something like and rose two 30.31% in 2005.

Now, something to note that this student is doing quite well is making comparisons. So for example, gas representing a smaller proportion than coal. They’re comparing gas to coal. And that’s fantastic. That is definitely showing that they’re higher than a typical band six student. So that’s a really good thing that they’re doing. Let’s keep going now and continue.

So with a dramatically smaller percentage. Okay. So they’re making a comparison again, which is nice. Nuclear and other types of energy production, both had a moderate rise in percentage where nuclear made up 10.1. And other kinds reached just under one tenth by 20 and five. So just in regards to here under one tenth, that is something that’s, that you should do when you’re writing about pie charts, you should try and use fractions.

Okay. So instead of always saying 10%, 20%, 33%, well you can do what this student has done. One tenth, one fifth, one third. This is going to show the examiner that you’ve got a wider range of vocabulary. Three that you can use. Now there is just one little mistake that I see with this word where okay, it shouldn’t be where it should probably be with nuclear making up 10.1% and other kinds, reaching just under one tenth by 2005.

So overall, this paragraph is pretty good. There’s some nice vocabulary. There’s some nice grammar. There are a few small issues, but they don’t really cause trouble for me, the reader, when I’m trying to understand what the writer is saying. However, or another issue was their topic sentence here, it’s not really clear what they’re going to talk about.

All right. Let’s keep going. Now. And let’s look at the second body paragraph. So moving on to Petro. Okay cool. So it looks like we’re going to talk about Petro. It was the only type of energy production which had a fall. Okay. Fantastic. That’s an important feature. Only type of energy production which had a fall. So now I can see what they’re going to talk about in this paragraph.

In this paragraph they’re going to talk about Petro because Petro went down. So that’s what the writer should have said up here. They should have said that in this paragraph. We’re going to look at the, data which had an increase. And that would have made it much clearer for that first body paragraph. But that’s okay. Let’s let’s go back down and, continue reading.

So the writer said, which had a fall in terms of percentage by 2005. Okay. Fantastic. Now the writer needs to give details and it looks like what? That’s what they’ve done. So they said it’s made up 29.27% of the energy production in 1995, but dramatically fell to just under one fifth of the energy production by 2005. Well, something I can see and I hope you can see it as well, is this repetition.

Okay, lots of repetition here. And that’s an issue when it comes to coherence and cohesion and even could affect, the vocabulary score. Now again please note here how the student has said one fifth okay. That’s fantastic. Instead of just always repeating the percentage, up here they’ve said 29.27%. So they’ve talked about the percentage and then they’ve said one fifth.

And that’s fantastic because they’re showing a variety of vocabulary. They’re just going back to, what the writer said here dramatically fell. Well, I think it would be a bit better and a bit more natural to say something like dropped significantly, significantly. That would be much more natural. So overall, this, final paragraph, I think it’s pretty, pretty nice.

You know, there’s a clear topic sentence. It tells the reader what’s going to be talked about. There’s some detail, there’s some nice vocabulary and there’s some nice grammar as well. But again, there are just some a few small issues that I talked about before. So, overall, I think the student has done a very nice job, but let’s give them a, band score for each of the four criteria.

Well, when it comes to task achievement, I would give them a seven because they have clearly talked about the most important features. The key features there, and they’ve made comparisons for coherence and cohesion. I’d also award, a seven because it’s definitely, definitely not a six, because a six means it’s just enough. It’s it’s okay. But this coherence, the way everything joins and flows together, it’s definitely more than just okay when it comes to lexical resource.

Again, I would definitely give it a seven. There’s not just basic vocabulary, there’s some less common vocabulary, but there are some small issues which stop it from getting to a band. Eight. And the main issue, probably in regards to getting to a band eight is there is not, a wide enough range to get to band eight.

And there are also some small mistakes, which we, talked about. Now, when it comes to grammar. I would also award a band seven because there is a range of structures. Most of the sentences are okay. And there are not many major errors. And if there are some errors, they don’t really affect the communication or the meaning of that sentence.

So definitely a seven for grammar there. It’s definitely better than a six because remember six is just enough. It’s okay. But there are some definitely some higher level, grammar structures in this, piece of writing. So overall, this student would definitely get a band 7.0 for their writing task one.

More lessons for you

Free IELTS PDF:
5 Mistakes Stopping You From Band 7+

Learn from an IELTS examiner how to fix these mistakes – plus get weekly IELTS lessons to your inbox.

IELTS Band 7+

Preparation Course 🚀

Improve Your IELTS Speaking in Minutes

Get our eBooks with 100s of common IELTS Speaking questions with band 7+ answers so you know exactly what to say.

Hot Deals 🔥

IELTS Speaking Part 1: Questions and Answers (eBook)

Get 5% off

IELTS Speaking Part 1: Questions and Answers (eBook)

Get 5% off

Free IELTS PDF:
5 Mistakes Stopping You From Band 7+

Learn from an IELTS examiner how to avoid 5 mistakes – and get weekly IELTS tips straight to your inbox.
100% free. Unsubscribe anytime. See Privacy Policy.